Among the many considerations when you are donating your eggs or looking for an egg donor, is how the UK legal position will impact you and also any future child. The UK only allows ID-release egg donations, which are widely recognized as being in the best interest of the future child by promoting access to medical information and supporting identity formation and well-being.
ID-release donors and the UK law
In the UK, egg donations are referred to as ID-release (non-anonymous) donations.
Currently, all donors and receiving parents remain anonymous to each other. Every care is taken to ensure that this confidentiality is maintained.
However, aged 18, donor-conceived people have the legal right to know who their donor is.
Regulations on anonymity introduced in 2005 mean that all children conceived as a result of gamete or embryo donation have the right at the age of 18 to receive identifying information about the donor (full name, last known address, date of birth, town or district of birth).
A donor has no legal responsibilities to any child created from a donation. The person who receives a donation (and their partner if they have one) will be the child’s legal and social parent(s). A donor is not named on the birth certificate and has no rights over how the child is brought up, and does not have to contribute financially.
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) Code of Practice permits a maximum of 10 families, including any subsequent siblings, as a result of donations from any single donor.
What information can the donor-conceived person access?
At the time of donation, a donor must provide their information to the HFEA (via the clinic), to be kept on a central register. It is the HFEA’s obligation to disclose the information to a donor-conceived adult who applies for this information.
If the donation took place before 1 April 2005, the information will be non-identifying; for any donations after that time, identifying information will be made available on request.
The HFEA must make an attempt to contact identifiable donors to alert them to a request for information before disclosing details to anyone born as a result of their donation.
An egg donor or sharer may request information about live births, birth year and number of children born as a result of her donated eggs.
Confidentiality
Set up in 1991, the HFEA’s register of information about donors, patients and treatments is confidential. It contains information concerning children conceived from licensed treatments from that date onwards.
A person conceived from donor treatment prior to April 2005 has the right to access:
- Anonymous information about the donor and any donor-conceived genetic siblings from age 16
- Information about the possibility of being related to the person they intend to marry or enter into a civil partnership with, at any age
- Information about the possibility of being related to the person they intend to enter into an intimate physical relationship with, from age 16
A person conceived from donor treatment after 1 April 2005 may also access:
- Identifying information about the donor (where applicable), from age 18
- Identifying information about donor conceived genetic siblings, with mutual consent, from age 18
ID-release donations and the emotional well-being of the donor-conceived child
The change of anonymity law in 2005 was introduced after the HFEA consulted widely with donor-conceived people and donors about how donor anonymity should work. The findings showed a desire on both sides to hold open an opportunity for potential future contact if the desire was mutual.
Common thinking dating from an earlier era of sperm donation was that the role of sperm donor should be kept secret from resulting children for their own well-being. As donor-conceived children and their experiences have become better understood, ideas on telling children about their genetic origins have fundamentally shifted.
Over time, understanding of children’s psychology around identity development has shown that disclosure of children’s origins helps them to understand their own relationships and themselves much better.
Disclosing donor identity is now believed to have emotional benefits for the child, who may be curious about physical or personality traits, or need to access the medical background of a donor. Fears that this disclosure would adversely affect relationships with parents and family have been seen to be unfounded. It is now believed that ID-release donations actually foster healthy family dynamics, by promoting openess and respecting the child's autonomy and right to make informed choices about their genetic heritage.
Useful Links
HFEA: rules about releasing donor information
https://www.hfea.gov.uk/donation/donors/rules-around-releasing-donor-information/
Donor conception network
Read more
Experiences of young adults born following egg donation, sperm donation, and surrogacy
A 2023 research article covers new ground and has positive answers directly from young adults themselves.
How does removing egg donor anonymity impact donors and donor-conceived people?
Greater openness in donor conception has led to positive changes for donors and donor-conceived people. It now makes it easier for adults born through donor conception to learn about their identities as donor offspring.